Quick answer
Herbal cigarettes are cigarettes made from dried herbs and other plant material instead of tobacco, so they usually contain no nicotine. They are still burned and inhaled as smoke, and the FTC has required sellers to warn that herbal cigarettes produce tar and carbon monoxide. Nicotine-free does not mean smoke-free, and that is the key difference from a zero nicotine vape.
Herbal cigarettes get pitched as a natural, tobacco-free way to keep a smoking ritual. Here at Vape Nicotine Free we sell zero nicotine disposables to adults 21+, and customers sometimes ask how the two compare. This guide covers what herbal smokes are, what federal regulators have said about them, and how they stack up against 0% vapes and other routines.
0 mg
Nicotine in most herbal smokes, since they contain no tobacco.
Tar + CO
What the FTC required herbal cigarette sellers to warn their products produce.
2000
Year the FTC settled charges over herbal cigarette health claims.
No flame
Zero nicotine vapes heat a liquid instead of burning plant material.
What are herbal cigarettes?
They look and burn like regular cigarettes, but the filler is a blend of dried plants instead of tobacco. Because there is no tobacco, most contain no nicotine.
They are sometimes sold as nicotine free cigarettes, tobacco free cigarettes, or herbal smokes. Some adults try them to keep the feel of smoking without nicotine. Whatever the reason, the defining feature is the same: you light the end, it burns, and you inhale smoke.
Are herbal cigarettes still harmful?
Yes, according to federal regulators, removing tobacco does not remove the problem of smoke. Burning plant material creates combustion byproducts no matter what the plant is.
In 2000, the Federal Trade Commission announced settlements with two companies over cigarette advertising, including one that marketed herbal cigarettes. The FTC alleged the company falsely implied its herbal cigarettes did not carry the health risks of tobacco cigarettes. According to the FTC’s analysis of the proposed consent order, the complaint said the herbal products’ smoke, like tobacco smoke, contains carcinogens and toxins including tar and carbon monoxide.
As part of the order, herbal cigarette packaging and ads had to carry this disclosure: “Herbal cigarettes are dangerous to your health. They produce tar and carbon monoxide.”

The same pattern shows up with herbal shisha
The CDC has reached a similar conclusion about another nontobacco smoking product. Its hookah fact page says smoke from both tobacco-based and herbal shisha contains carbon monoxide and other toxic agents, and that studies do not support marketing claims that nontobacco products are less harmful.
Key point: Nicotine and smoke are two separate issues. Herbal cigarettes remove nicotine but keep combustion. A zero nicotine vape removes nicotine and combustion, but it still produces an aerosol and is not risk-free.
No tobacco, no nicotine, no flame
Our zero nicotine disposables heat a flavored liquid instead of burning anything. Free shipping over $100, and save 10% on 2 or 15% on 3 or more.
Shop zero nicotine vapesHerbal cigarettes vs tobacco cigarettes vs 0% vapes
Here is how the three compare on the factors adults ask us about most.
| Factor | Tobacco cigarettes | Herbal cigarettes | Zero nicotine vapes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contains tobacco | Yes | No | No |
| Contains nicotine | Yes | Usually no | No, in a true 0% product |
| Burns (combustion) | Yes | Yes | No, heats a liquid |
| Produces tar and carbon monoxide | Yes | Yes, per the FTC | No combustion; aerosol still contains chemicals |
| Smoke or aerosol | Smoke | Smoke | Aerosol |
| Risk-free | No | No | No |
For scale, the FDA says there are more than 7,000 chemicals in tobacco cigarette smoke and more than 70 are linked to cancer, and the CDC notes that secondhand smoke from burning tobacco products contains hundreds of toxic chemicals. Herbal smoke has a different makeup, but the FTC case shows it still contains tar and carbon monoxide.
How zero nicotine vapes compare
A zero nicotine vape keeps the device in hand and the flavor, but swaps burning for heating. That removes tar and carbon monoxide from combustion, though it does not make vaping risk-free.
The Cleveland Clinic notes that nicotine-free vapes still expose users to compounds formed when propylene glycol, glycerin, and flavorings are heated, and that some products sold as nicotine-free have contained nicotine. We explain how we choose our brands in our nicotine-free vapes buyer’s guide.
Some adults use a 0% device to keep the hand-to-mouth routine while cutting out nicotine. That is a habit choice, not a quit-smoking method. If you want to quit smoking, Smokefree.gov and your healthcare provider can point you to FDA-approved options.

Other ways to keep the ritual without smoke
If what you miss is the routine more than the product, a few simple swaps can fill the gap.
- Something in your hand: A pen, stress ball, or fidget item can stand in during habitual moments.
- Something in your mouth: Sugar-free gum, mints, or a toothpick are easy options.
- A flavor ritual: Some adults prefer a 0% vape in a familiar profile. Browse our tobacco flavor vapes or read about tobacco-style blends without nicotine.
- No flavor at all: Our article on flavorless 0% vapes covers neutral options.
- Aromatherapy devices: These are different again; see herbal diffuser pens vs nicotine-free vapes.
Smoking rules still apply to herbal smokes
Because an herbal cigarette is lit and produces smoke, most no-smoking rules cover it. Hotels, rental agreements, workplaces, and public venues typically ban smoking in general, not just tobacco.
The same courtesy logic applies to vaping. Zero nicotine vapes do not burn, but they still release aerosol into shared air, and many venues ban vaping alongside smoking. When in doubt, step outside to a designated area and follow posted signs.
Choosing a 0% vape instead: what to look for
If you have decided a smoke-free, nicotine-free device is a better fit for your routine than nicotine free cigarettes, a few checks help you pick well.
- Confirm 0 mg nicotine. Buy from a retailer that clearly lists nicotine content, since the Cleveland Clinic notes that some products sold as nicotine-free have contained nicotine.
- Pick a familiar flavor family. Former smokers often start with mint, menthol-style, or tobacco-style blends.
- Match the size to your habit. Occasional users may prefer a compact device; daily users often want 20K puffs or more.
- Check the features. Rechargeable batteries, adjustable ice, and airflow controls change the experience.
Our guide on how to choose the right zero nicotine vape walks through each step in more detail.
Herbal smokes by the numbers
5 to 0
FTC Commission vote to accept the proposed consent agreements in 2000.
$11,000
Civil penalty per violation once the FTC orders became final.
7,000+
Chemicals in tobacco cigarette smoke, per the FDA.
70+
Of those chemicals linked to cancer, per the FDA.
Zero nicotine picks for former smokers
Mint and crisp fruit flavors are popular starting points for adults moving away from smoking rituals. All contain 0 mg nicotine.
Find your smoke-free routine
Every device in our shop is zero nicotine. Mix flavors to get 10% off 2 or 15% off 3 or more, plus free shipping over $100.
Browse 0% disposablesFrequently asked questions
Do herbal cigarettes have nicotine?
Most herbal cigarettes contain no tobacco and therefore no nicotine. Check the ingredient list, since products vary.
Are herbal cigarettes harmful?
Yes, they still carry risks. The FTC required herbal cigarette sellers to warn that herbal cigarettes are dangerous to your health and produce tar and carbon monoxide.
Are herbal cigarettes better than tobacco cigarettes?
Herbal cigarettes remove nicotine but still involve burning and inhaling smoke. The CDC says studies do not support claims that nontobacco smoking products like herbal shisha are less harmful.
How are herbal cigarettes different from zero nicotine vapes?
Herbal cigarettes burn plant material and create smoke. Zero nicotine vapes heat a liquid into an aerosol without combustion. Neither is risk-free.
Can herbal cigarettes help you quit smoking?
Herbal cigarettes are not an approved quit-smoking aid. Smokefree.gov and your healthcare provider can help you find FDA-approved options.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission: FTC Accepts Settlements of Charges that Alternative Cigarette Ads Are Deceptive (2000)
- Federal Trade Commission: Analysis of Proposed Consent Order, Alternative Cigarettes, Inc. (2000)
- CDC: Hookahs (2024)
- FDA: Chemicals in Cigarettes: From Plant to Product to Puff
- CDC: About Secondhand Smoke (2024)
- Cleveland Clinic: Nicotine-Free Vaping: What You Should Know (2026)
For adults 21+ only. This article is for general information and is not medical advice. Zero nicotine vapes contain no nicotine, but they are not risk-free; talk with a healthcare provider about your health questions.

